Guide
What Are Ghost Jobs? How to Identify Fake or Inactive Job Advertisements
Published 15 November 2026 · Updated 15 November 2026
A ghost job is a public job advertisement for a position that does not exist, or that the employer is not planning to fill in the near term. You cannot prove that from the ad text alone. Posting age, reposts and a closed status are reasons to investigate, not a verdict.
What public sources mean by ghost job
The US Congressional Research Service describes ghost job postings as online ads for positions that do not exist, or that employers are not planning to fill immediately. The same briefing says there are no official statistics on how common they are. kery.io does not invent a percentage to fill that gap. (CRS, “Ghost” Job Postings, IF12977)
Reporting from the BBC describes ads that were never meant to be filled, and ads that stay up after someone is hired. Employer surveys quoted in that coverage are not government counts. (BBC Worklife)
SHRM notes that evergreen hiring, a slow process, or a neglected take-down can look like a ghost job even when the role was real when it was posted. (SHRM)
How a ghost job differs from other stale ads
| Pattern | What you can actually see | What it does not prove |
|---|---|---|
| Ghost job | A listing stays public with little sign the employer is hiring now. | Motive. An outsider cannot see budget approval or an internal candidate. |
| Closed or expired ad | The board says applications are no longer accepted. | Whether the role was filled, frozen, or simply not removed. |
| Repost | The same role comes back, or the visible posted date resets. | A new vacancy. Some boards refresh the date on the same job ID. |
| Long-running vacancy | The ad has been up for a long time and is still accepting applications. | Bad faith. Hiring can be slow, selective, or for more than one person. |
A short example
A “Marketing Operations Manager” ad on a job board shows “posted 2 weeks ago”. The same job ID was first visible six months earlier, and the company careers page has no matching role. That is a reason to ask the recruiter whether the role is open. It is not proof the ad is fake. A staffing agency can also keep an ad up while a real client interview is underway.
What you can check before you apply
- Save the exact job URL and any job ID, so a date refresh is not mistaken for a new vacancy.
- Read the board’s own posted date and any “not accepting applications” label.
- Search the company, title and location on the company careers site and one other board.
- If you can, ask who the hiring manager is and what the interview steps are. Silence is common on real jobs too.
The longer version is how to identify ghost jobs before applying. Reposts have their own guide: why companies keep reposting the same job.
Where kery.io fits, and where it stops
The ghost job checker estimates High, Medium or Low risk from listing age, verified reposts, closed status and related postings on jobs you add. It does not see applicant counts or hiring decisions. Method and limits: methodology.
Questions people ask
Is every old job ad a ghost job?
No. Some roles stay open because hiring is slow or the employer is hiring more than one person.
Are ghost jobs the same as job scams?
No. A scam asks you for money, identity documents, or to install something. A ghost job is an ad that is not an active hire. Treat those as separate problems.
Can a score prove a listing is fake?
No. Public posting history cannot prove intent. Use it to decide how much time the application deserves.